Performance comparison

Same computer, lighter to use

We installed Pomelo 0.35 and regular Ubuntu 24.04 in identical virtual machines and measured boot time, memory and disk. Below are the measured numbers for each item, along with exactly how we measured.

405MB
Memory used at idle (Ubuntu about 990 MB, 59% less)
4.2s
Boot fully finished (Ubuntu 25.1 s, 6x faster)
2.1GB
Disk used after installing (Ubuntu 10.2 GB, 79% less)
1.30GB
Install disc size (Ubuntu 6.25 GB, 79% less)
Full results

Item by item

Numbers are the middle result of 3 runs (the median); memory and process counts are the average of 3 runs.

ItemRegular Ubuntu 24.04 (GNOME)Pomelo 0.35Difference
Boot to desktop (about 3 s of firmware included)8.8 s7.2 s1.6 s faster (18%)
Boot fully finished25.1 s4.2 s6x faster
First boot to desktop after installing62.8 s9.4 s6.7x faster
Memory used when idle990 MB405 MB59% less
Memory used by the desktop itself359 MB114 MB68% less
Processes22715532% less
Running services321456% less
CPU at idle≈ 0%≈ 0%Same
Disk used after install10.2 GB2.1 GB79% less
Packages150863458% less
Snap packages100No Snap
Install disc size6.25 GB1.30 GB79% less
Install time22.4 min3.4 minUbuntu includes downloading updates, so it can't be compared directly
How we compared

Both sides set up as alike as possible

  • Identical virtual machines: QEMU + KVM, UEFI, 4 CPUs, 4 GB memory, 40 GB disk, on the same host
  • Pomelo: the install disc's automatic install (erases the whole disk)
  • Ubuntu: the official 24.04.5.1 desktop disc (SHA256 verified), using the official automatic install with the default minimal installation
  • Both are set to log in automatically, and the measuring script runs over the serial port without opening any window, so the extra load is the same
  • Every boot: a screenshot every 0.5 seconds, and the moment the screen stops changing counts as "desktop appeared"; after 150 seconds idle, the same script measures memory and the other numbers
  • Ubuntu's first boot after installing has to set up Snap, so it is recorded separately; after that, we took 3 normal boots for each

How we handled the measuring

  • Nothing else was running on the host during measurement
  • For Pomelo, 3 boots happened while the host was running other tests and 1 hit a filesystem check; those 4 were thrown out and 3 more were measured
Being honest

How to read these numbers

  • "Desktop appeared" is only 1.6 s apart: in a virtual machine both sides spend about 3 seconds in firmware and about 2 seconds in the kernel, so those 5 seconds are the same. The real gap is when the system finishes its work: GNOME draws the desktop in 9 seconds, but the background (snapd, update checks, calendar data service...) keeps busy until 25 seconds, and apps open slower during that time; on a traditional hard drive, that background activity also competes with you for the disk. Pomelo is completely done in 4 seconds.
  • Memory: Ubuntu uses about 585 MB more, mainly from gnome-shell (359 MB), the calendar and contacts services, snapd and the update checker. On an old computer with 4 GB, the difference is very noticeable.
  • Install time can't be compared directly: Ubuntu's automatic install downloads security updates over the network, so part of its 22 minutes is spent downloading; Pomelo's install needs no network. Disc size, however, can be compared directly.
  • The kernel versions differ: the official 24.04.5 disc ships a newer kernel (7.0), while Pomelo's 24.04 edition uses the original kernel (6.8). The kernel boots in 2.1 seconds on both sides, so it doesn't affect the results.
  • These were measured in virtual machines. On real computers (especially older ones with a traditional hard drive and little memory) the gap is usually larger, but we haven't measured that, so we don't give numbers.